QUOTE (SCHG @ May 5 2009, 04:38 PM)

QUOTE (surf and dune @ May 5 2009, 01:51 PM)

QUOTE (SCHG @ May 5 2009, 01:00 PM)

QUOTE (adamwn @ May 5 2009, 12:51 AM)

Putting a healthy 4 year old dog to death just because they can't care for it is TOTAL BS!! And it should be illegal or not allowed, if it even is allowed. People should not have the right to take any healthy dog to a pound and have it killed. Dogs picked up off the street are given a chance to be adopted, so why not this dog?
Will pounds really kill a healthy young dog at the owners request? Or will they say no and just take it in and give it the same deal as a stray?
The more I think about it the less I beleive they would just kill for the hell of it. Think about it, if a owner kills his healthy dog they would be appearing before a judge in hand cuffs for felony animal cruelty. But if the owner has a city worker kill the dog it's fine? I really don't think so. Anyone know for sure?
Also haven't these people heard of "no kill shelters"?
So its better for the dog to suffer emotional trauma than to go to "sleep"? Let's see - torture the dog emotionally - put the dog to sleep....hmmm....that makes a lot of sense.Will a vet or an organization put a dog down because the owner asks - yes they will. I had to put my two and a half year old beagle to sleep. I went to the vet, asked them to put her down and they did. It was the worst thing Ive EVER had to do.
Euthanasia is a very HUMANE way of dealing with animals. I wish that all the owners of the dogs I see running around lose and running in and out of traffic would have put their dogs down - then I wouldn't be seeing so many smashed and dead on the road.
People - let's not forget that they are animals...they aren't children - we love them yes - there's no doubt - but they are animals.
I don't know that we can pass judgement on these people without knowing all the facts involved.
Should they try the allergist first - yes - I know I would - but in this economy - who knows if they have the money. I know what the orthopeadic vet costs for my boxers broken leg and it wasn't pretty - 8 weeks of casts and specialized vets in addition to her regular vet - we were lucky - we had the money but in this economy - who knows if these people have the money.
I think Courtney should be applauded for trying to help and these people need to be cut some slack.
Until anyone of us has walked a mile in their shoes in this particular situation - we have no right to pass judgement.
I'm sorry I can't take her Courtney!
You have got to be effin kidding me!
Kill the dog instead of either spending a reasonable amount of time to find another home for it, or giving it a fighting chance at the pound? I hope to h--l you didn't kill your 2 year old beagle for similar reasons. And $$ shouldn't be the deciding factor either since they somehow had the cash to landscape in the first place. Also, one last time, if your pet is sick, old, suffering etc., sometimes you have to make that hard decision to "put it down", I have had to make that decision myself more than once. But when you take a perfectly healthy, happy pet, and decide its just not convienent to have anymore( or you don't want it to suffer
emotional trauma) and end its life, you are killing it. Sorry, I know the other term might make you feel better but it is what it is. BTW. I have two dogs myself, both are about 10 yrs old and I got them both from the pound. They seem to have gotten over all of that emotional trauma they went through a long time ago.
Courtney, I applaud you for trying to help out and I'm not directing any of my comments toward you , in fact I edited my first post cause I was a bit out of line with one of my comments about your freinds. Good luck.
This is exactly the kind of judgement passing that I was talking about. No one on this board with the exception of Courtney knows two I eat poos about what these people and their dog are going through.
My ONLY point is that there are times and extenuating circumstances wherein it is more HUMANE to put the dog down than to allow it to suffer.
Obviously they are trying to find a suitable home for the dog since that's why Courtney posted this. The other obvious fact is that if the dog was "
happy and healthy" in their home they wouldn't be doing this.
And as for your comment about my beagle - you definitely don't know two I eat poos about that I'm certainly not going to justify myself to you or anyone else about it. I can guarantee - had she attacked your child - you would feel differently.
Did you even read the original post?! (See statements in red)
"EVERYTHING was GREAT until we LANDSCAPED the back yard"
"WORST THING is she doesn't like to ride in the car."
That sounds like a pretty happy healthy dog to me, and it sounds like Honey has a lot of love to give.
By the way, landscaping does not count as "extenuating circumstances wherein it is more HUMANE to put the dog down than to allow it to suffer."
Cancer, yes. Chronic pain from say, hip displacia, yes. A FREAKING HOUSE PLANT, hell no!
EFF them, EFF them, EFF them.
- 4 yrs old female, spayed chipped and current.
- Choc lab, Golden retriever mix.
- honey brown coat and golden eyes.
-
Just very affectionate, craves the petting and attention - GREAT with kids ( my 4yr old doesn't just love Honey, she wants to BE Honey, and
Honey loves it) - a companion dog for my 10yr old yellow lab-
- a very good watch dog
- crate trained (sleeps in crate, and also when no one is home)
- house trained and does not get on furniture
-
loves to be at our feet, where ever we are (
worst thing is she doesn't like to ride in the car, she gets car sick!) Comes with her crate and food!
We have had her since she was 6 wks old, she was a birthday gift for my husband.
Everything was great until we landscaped the back yard, and now she has skin allergies (scratching and biting herself) and is miserable. We have tried for a year to find a "desert home" for Honey, and no such luck. We are afraid to take her to the pound, since they are so overcrowded and she has allergies, I think they will just put her to sleep. We have decided the best thing is to put her down ourselves, at least we can be with her, and she won't be frightened and lonely and scared to death. It's breaking my heart, Her appointment is Saturday.
Let me know what you think.