Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Testimony On Demo Fee
GlamisDunes.com > Sand Community Issues > Glamis Issues
The Pastor
May 19 2004, 09:51 AM
QUOTE
 
The recreation industry has finally shown its fee-demo hand. Not even the
hole-card is left unturned. And now that everything is in plain view, I
invite you to look at what they're holding and decide to call, or fold, as
you see fit. You may not be seated at the table, but what's been wagered
belongs to you as much as it belong to those holding the cards. It's not too
late for you to get involved.

The recreation industry turned over their final down card on May 6th, 2004
when Christine Jourdain, representing both the American Council of
Snowmobile Associations and the American Recreation Coalition, testified
before the House Resources Subcommittee on National Parks, Recreation and
Public Lands. What Jourdain told Congress will cause jaws to drop amongst
those who have not followed the issue. It will likely cause heart
palpitations amongst those who have hoped, or perhaps prayed, that anti-fee
opponents were wrong in their long-standing claim that fee-demo is part of a
bigger agenda.

The full testimony can be read at
http://www.wildwilderness.org/docs/jourdain.htm
A concise and stinging, paragraph-by-paragraph summary of Jourdain's
testimony appears below.  I strongly encourage you to read it and then read
the original to assure yourself that I have been faithful in my
paraphrasing.

The bottom line is this --- the table is piled high with chips with the fate
of outdoor recreation on America's public lands at stake. Read what fee
proponents shared with Congress and then decide whether you are prepared to
let them walk away with what is now yours or whether you're prepared to call
their bluff.

It is only a bluff. The recreation industry is not holding sufficiently high
cards that it can beat the whole of the American People, no matter how hard
they may try. They may be powerful, but they are not that powerful -- at
least, not yet.

Scott

---- Paragraph by Paragraph Summary follows ---

#1 My name is Christine Jourdain and I am today speaking on behalf of  25
state snowmobile associations plus to more than 100 member corporations of
the American Recreation Coalition.

#2 We thank Mr. Regula for having been our inside man and for having
implemented the Recreation Fee Demonstration Program which we created and
helped write.

#3 We want to stress that fees are just only one tool in our privatization
toolbox. Other tools include increased agency dependence upon volunteerism,
partnerships and more.

#4 Twenty years ago a couple of recreation industry leaders had a vision.

#5 Those leaders created the American Recreation Coalition they acted upon
that vision. Working with President Reagan, we laid out a path that would
lead to the day our vision became reality.

#6 We applaud the committee for what it's so-far done to implement that
vision.

#7 We consider the first 7 year fee-demonstration program has been a
success. We now call upon you to pass our new-and-improved, Phase Two
demonstration program.

#8 We want you to know that we support the basic principles of HR 3283, but
that bill does not go far enough. Not by a long way.

#9 We almost hate to say this, but we will NOT support HR 3283 in it's
present form.

#10 Our biggest concern is that this legislation doesn't give us control of
the program nor does it give us management control of the public lands.
We're concerned that if we were to pass HR 3283 today, it will be difficult
for us to come back and take what we left sitting on the table.

#11 Our next biggest concern is that some public lands are not included
within this program. We insist that every last federal land management
agency be included.

#12 We are also very pissed that some agency personnel are overcharging our
outfitters, guides, concessionaires and other private recreation-service
providers. This needs to be corrected and one of our other Board members
will testify on that issue later in this hearing.

#13 In order to ensure nothing like that every happens again, we want
Congress to create a new "National Recreation Fees Advisory Board" upon
which our members would sit. This board would effectively control the
program,  would report directly to congress and would determine how and
where fees were collected and spent.

#14 We also want to have Congress establish a slush-fund into which money
from existing fee sites can be deposited and from which money can be
withdrawn, as necessary, to develop currently undeveloped sites in
anticipation of charging new fees at those sites. Perhaps we'll call this
'the build in and they will pay fund'.

#15 We have been frustrated that there are still wage laws in this country
which, quite frankly, have been giving us fits. We also know there are
millions of Americans who are being excluded from their public lands because
of these fees. So here are a few idea we've proposing for changing the law
and getting around those annoying problems.

#16 We also want Congress to give an even bigger cash incentive to outsource
the management of public recreation facilities. Let our friends run a public
recreation site and we're prepared to give the agency a 10% cut of whatever
fees we collect... but no more than that!

#17 We also want Congress to rely more fully on public-private-partnerships
and upon a new gimmick we're calling: "Non-Appropriated Funding
Instrumentatlities" (NAFI). You'll recognize NAFI as gas-tax money,
recreation trails fund (RTF) money, highway budgets, scenic byways dollars,
state-side contributions from LWCF and a dozen other off-budget funds. We
intend not only to use these sources to replace appropriated dollars, we
(acting though our new Fee Advisory Board) intend to exert ultimate control
over how these funds are spent and through that control, control of the
lands themselves.

#18 And finally, we want the Fee Advisory Board to be giving new authority
to start charging for things that congress has long prohibited -- things
such as the use of drinking fountains, undeveloped parking areas,  scenic
overlooks, toilets and individual picnic tables.

#19 Thank you all for coming today.  If any of you Congressmen have
questions, I have brought with me ARC's President, Derrick Crandall, and
several ARC members and staffers. We will be happy to explain in greater
detail exactly what we expect of you.

#20 If you'd like to contact me, my name, once again, is Christine Jourdain
and you can call me at (517) 351-4362 or drop me an e-mail at
cajourdain@aol.com

So ends the testimony of Christine Jourdain.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Scott Silver
Wild Wilderness
248 NW Wilmington Ave.
Bend, OR  97701

phone:      541-385-5261
e-mail:      ssilver@wildwilderness.org
Internet:    http://www.wildwilderness.org

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.