Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Lies from The Nature Conservancy
GlamisDunes.com > Sand Community Issues > Glamis Issues
SailAway
Of all the bad guys in the environmental industry, The Nature Conservancy is one of the biggest and the baddest. Here's just a sample:

The Nature Conservancy's "outrageous contradictions and sad lies."

Review by J. Zane Walley
Executive Director, Paragon America

"Twelve million acres in the U.S., an area the size of Switzerland,is controlled by The Nature Conservancy"

The most shocking expose in America today is in a new publication from RANGE magazine. In "Nature's Landlord," investigative reporter Tim Findley explores "the world's most powerful environmental group, The Nature Conservancy." Findley calls TNC "the monster we made from indifference" and shows how it has carefully and methodically achieved global power on a scale few could imagine. He traces the history of the TNC from its modest origins to its current status as a behemoth with nearly $3 billion (tax-exempt) and worldwide control of some 90 million acres. Twelve million acres in the U.S., an area the size of Switzerland, is controlled by the TNC.

"Nature's Landlord" is not just a compendium of facts and figures. It is a masterpiece of brilliant writing that will fascinate readers. You'll meet "the shyly informed college boy in his neatly pressed blue work shirt" who insinuated his way into the heart of a small community. His real goal was to "seek weaknesses"-people who could be pressured into selling off their land. The TNC admits that it "helps the government get around the problem of local opposition" to property acquisition. TNC, cloaked in environmental benevolence, buys "these properties when they need to be bought, so that at some point we can become willing seller" to the government. As one 75-year-old rancher and poet said, "I had no choice, really. They [the TNC] bought everything around me. I'm just tired of fighting with 'em." The "college boy" who watched her lose her home is now the head of TNC in California.

Ranches across the West have fallen into the hands of TNC "like overripe fruit dropping from a shaken tree." On Virginia's Eastern Shore there was once a sustainable system of food production and ecology, but TNC changed all that. Operating covertly under a variety of names, TNC "saved" the area, putting a largely minority labor force out of work, deepening the scourge of poverty in the area. The "saved" islands were "served with opulent showplaces built for rich clients, all unaffordable to the people of the Eastern Shore."

Findley exposes many more instances of TNC's "outrageous contradictions and sad lies." He points to the mineral, gas and oil rights acquired by TNC under the guise of "saving" lands. For instance, TNC "saved" an endangered bird only to pump at least $5.5 million worth of oil and gas royalties, so far, from beneath its habitat. A million acres of timberland in Maine and New Hampshire are logged by TNC. A swath of American land larger than the state of Delaware was traded to a foreign power without a word from the American press and public. Two million acres of TNC land in the United States was swapped to the government of Brazil in exchange for Amazon rainforest.

It's not just member contributions that sustain TNC. Its chairman says trolling for 25-buck members is wasted effort. Appealing to wealthy corporations is "just a greater return." Besides, between 1995 and 2000, TNC raked in more than $32 million from the U.S. government-your tax dollars at work.

A report by professional ecologist Jeff Goodson on "The Network," describes a system of data centers with nearly 300 centers worldwide that collect and dispense biodiversity data, and include support for land-use planning, environmental impact assessment and endangered species management. Tax dollars and wealthy foundations supported TNC's program that has become "an environmental espionage and land-targeting program" that "collaborates closely" with the federal government.

It is future generations we should be concerned about, Findley writes. We need to bring "some accountability to a small group of people with grossly exaggerated power and authority over fundamental elements of a free society."

Copies of the 24-page, 4-color report "Nature's Landlord" are available from the RANGE (1-800-726-4348) while supplies last. Copies of RANGE magazine including "Nature's Landlord" are also available.
fnmeyers
What does this have to do with Glamis Dunes Issues?
SailAway
quote:
Originally posted by 5thgear:
What does this have to do with Glamis Dunes Issues?

From a distance:

quote:
This forum is designed to inform you on Glamis Dunes closure related issues, along with other land use issues across the states. Feel free to ask questions, post information, or place articles in this forum pertaining to these matters. Enjoy your stay.
More to the point though...

Glamis is being closed by groups like this, one parcel at a time. The former Desert District Manager for Glamis was a strong supporter of The Nature Conservancy and the next one could be too.

Most important though, is the policy "Know Thine Enemy."

The more we know the stronger we are.

Vicki

[ 02-13-2003, 02:15 PM: Message edited by: SailAway ]
fnmeyers
Cool..my bad.

Basically what seperates TNC from groups like Sierra Club or the CBD is that TNC does not go though all the legal crap and hold thing up in the system.

They basically just buy the land they want to protect and do with it what they want. Is there anything against that? I think it's a great idea. And the last time I checked, the dunes are not for sale. So I don't think TNC is going to get their paws on this one. Unless they strike a land swap with the BLM.

If I had to support one of these groups it would be TNC (although I never would). My $ goes to the Blue Ribbon Coalition.
SailAway
Egad. I had a long rant poised in response to you 5thGear, but something fritzed and I lost it before it posted.

So I took a walk and wondered if you might just be pulling my leg [Cool]

Or maybe not... heck, once upon a time I was a card-carrying member of the Sierra Club so anything's possible [Eek!]

At any rate, the walk helped me focus and the bottom line is we each have the right to support whichever group we choose (and their tactics), so the rant will stay in limbo [Big Grin]

Vicki

[ 02-13-2003, 04:53 PM: Message edited by: SailAway ]
Fireballsocal
[Quote]Operating covertly under a variety of names, TNC "saved" the area, putting a largely minority labor force out of work, deepening the scourge of poverty in the area.[Quote]

This is the kicker here. Lies, deception, and lots of money, all in the name of good. You say they basically just buy the land and do what they want with it. What they want includes the mining, timber cutting, and selling off large quantities of land to Brazil and the government. That doesn't sound like conserving to me but you go ahead and think what you want.
SailAway
That's just the tip of the iceberg Ben [Frown]

They may not sue to close land (like the CBD) but they "partner" with organizations like the CBD and the California Native Plant Society. CNPS filed a lawsuit to have critical habitat designated for the PMV. And since it (allegedly) only grows at the ISDRA, that makes Glamis the critical habitat they seek. So, while they may not be coming at Glamis directly, they sure are supporting (and funding) the organizations that are.

I used to believe the warm and fuzzy stuff like "clean air and water" (Sierra Club) and "we just want to save the children" (Bluewater Network who is petitioning to ban the sale of ATVs) but I've learned what is behind these facades.

As for The Nature Conservency, even if I liked their politics I sure wouldn't like their tactics. Lies, deception and downright cheating, unethical to the core.

Oh, and I am a member of the BRC also and they surely don't even come close to supporting The Nature Conservency -- just didn't want anyone thinking they did.

Vicki
Fireballsocal
What I was getting at was normal activities are carried out under the name TNC while activities that will cause a backlash from their funding host are carried out under various other names. The CBD, Earth First, and others of their ilk may be linked to TNC or draw funding from them. Just because TNC isn't threatening Glamis doesn't mean that one of their subsideries isn't.
SailAway
I couldn't agree more.

Vicki
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.