Well, well, very interesting concept.
As I read through this, the real point became clearer and clearer. It's not about who does or doesn't contribute in some way to the sport, it's about targeting an specific builder who was described slowly through several posts.
First, when selecting a product, I look at the product itself, how well does it perform? I don't give a rat's ass if the builder has a hot wife, or he's a really nice guy or he has a mullet. I'm not marrying him or his wife, so none of that crap matters.
A TRUE giver would donate to causes that do NOT directly affect one's industry. Spending money to preserve ones' livelihood is campaigning or lobbying - NOT donating, to make that distinction clear.
When somebody gets a back injury and suddenly starts donating to that cause... are they generous, or hoping to benefit from it? Donate to what affects others and not yourself, and then you might be called generous or selfless.
I DO applaud those who have the time and/or money to fight for the cause, WHICHEVER org they choose to contribute to. That doesn't mean I'm gonna buy their rail, or that it's better or in any way gets any more consideration than others. It's like buying a car just because you liked the hot chick in the ad on TV...
sorry, you have to buy her separately.

When someone cries wolf, I look for consistency - do as I do, not as I say. Did somebody get all in Toyota's face about their level of support of offroading? Why not? They've got BIG bucks to spend. They could take on the enviros dollar for dollar and win.
How about Yamaha? They made your Raptor. Is that why you chose to support Yamaha? Because of their incredible support for our hobby (industry)? Noo... you liked the bike, despite their lack of corp. support.
I use the same criteria to choose everything. Cars, rails, boats, bikes, electronics. Which one is the best within my budget.
There are soooo many other factors that go into deciding which rail is safest, handles, rides, looks, etc the way that I want, that what somebody ate for breakfast has the same relevance as who they donate to.
Here's how I see it. Buy whatever rail you think is safest, etc. Then donate whatever amouint you want to whichever org you want to. It's none of anyone else's business what you donate to.
If you're using donations to separate good from bad... I'm pretty sure 80% of this planet are gonna fall in the bad category.